Druidry in the Face of Climate Change

an invitation to virtual tea, and deep discussion among fellow Druids

(but first, a bit of background)

The Fourth National Climate Assessment (NCA4), Volume II, recently published by the United States Global Change Research Program (2018), summarizes the findings of the earlier, 2017 Climate Science Special Report (CSSR), Volume I, and then lays out, in great detail,

“…the human welfare, societal, and environmental elements of climate change and variability for 10 regions and 18 national topics, with particular attention paid to observed and projected risks, impacts, consideration of risk reduction, and implications under different mitigation pathways. Where possible, NCA4 Volume II provides examples of actions underway in communities across the United States to reduce the risks associated with climate change, increase resilience, and improve livelihoods.”

Climate change is a topic of great concern to Druids – and for many of us it is also a source of great distress – because our religious beliefs stress the sanctity of Mother Earth and all Living Beings who dwell upon her (and within her various biospheres), and because our spiritual paths and lifestyle choices are driven by an ethic of care toward All Living Beings. So, what is a Druid to do in the face of global climate change?

If we fail to remain focused on our (meaning the specific Druids engaged in the conversation; not a vague referral to “humanity” in general) sphere of influence, rather than the infinite and terrifying and paralyzing sphere of concern, there is a tendency for people to go off on rants about what “people” should have done in back the 70s, when we first should have known about this, or what “people” need to do now. It is a waste of energy, and tends to lead people to despair and inaction.

I am interested in brainstorming on what we, as a small group of scattered Druids, can do concretely, to maximize our utility to ourselves, to our families, and to our wider communities, in the face of the dramatic changes that have already arrived, as well as those which are likely yet to come. But before we can generate plausible, actionable strategies, we must understand the science, the ecology, and the socio-economic contexts that will serve to constrain our viable solution-space.

Therefore, beginning in January 2019, the World Fellowship of Druids will be hosting a series of biweekly discussions (via private Google Hangouts), to discuss the findings presented in The Fourth National Climate Assessment (NCA4), Volume II report, a few chapters at at time. Based upon our growing understanding of those findings, and the scientific analyses underlying them, we will discuss what types of concrete, Druid responses would be both feasible and most wise, so that we can as a group offer help and solace, and act as pillars of hope and light, in times that can often seem quite dark.

I hope you will consider adding your voice to this important conversation.

Schedule of Readings (due: first and third Saturdays)

Saturday 5 January 2019
Front Matter
Chapter 1: Overview

Saturday 19 January 2019
Chapter 2: Our Changing Climate (review of climate science)

Saturday 2 February 2019
Chapter 3: Water
Chapter 4: Energy Supply, Delivery & Demand
Chapter 5: Land Cover & Land Use Change

Saturday 16 February 2019
Chapter 6: Forests
Chapter 7: Ecosystems, Ecosystem Services, and Biodiversity

Saturday 2 March 2019
Chapter 8: Coastal Effects
Chapter 9: Oceans & Marine Resources

Saturday 16 March 2019
Chapter 10: Agriculture & Rural Communities
Chapter 11: Built Environment, Urban Systems, and Cities

Saturday 6 April 2019
Chapter 12: Transportation
Chapter 13: Air Quality
Chapter 14: Human Health

Saturday 20 April 2019
Chapter 15: Tribes and Indigenous Peoples
Chapter 16: Climate Effects on U.S. International Interests
Chapter 17: Sector Interactions, Multiple Stressors, Complex Systems

Saturday 4 May 2019
Read ONE of the ten, lengthy, “Regions” Chapters
(choose the one for the region in which you currently live),
Meditate fully upon what that chapter has to say to you about the climate change effects that hit closest to home, and how they relate to your life.

Saturday 25 May 2019 (NOTE: this final discussion is on a  4th Saturday!)
Chapter 28: Reducing Risks through Adaptation Actions
Chapter 29: Reducing Risks through Emissions Mitigation

Discussion topics and times will be posted to the World Fellowship Members page, two weeks in advance of each scheduled discussion. If you choose to sign up to participate, you will be sent information on how to access that information.

How to Participate

  1. Sign up for the World Fellowship of Druids discussion group. (Please note your time zone in the bit about your home biome, to help with finding a time that works for all participants.)
  2. Note the date and time for our next discussion, mark your calendar, and RSVP so that you are sure to be invited into the private Google Hangout, when the appointed time arrives.
  3. Read the assigned chapters listed for each date BEFORE the scheduled discussion time.
  4. Be at your Google Hangouts enabled device, cup of tea (or something stronger) in hand, and ready to receive your invitation when it comes.

I look forward to having your voice in the discussion!

Larisa

Contemporary Druidry

Contemporary Druidry: A Historical and Ethnographic Study,” by Michael T. Cooper, is an academic study of modern Druidry, written by a non-Druid, associate professor of Religion and Contemporary Culture, at Trinity Graduate School in Deerfield, IL.

The book is divided into two main parts: a brief overview of the history of Druidry, and an ethnographic study, based on a combination of field observations and interviews conducted with a rather small sampling of 56 practicing Druids, primarily members of ADF (Ár nDraíocht Féin), OBOD (Order of Bards, Ovates, and Druids), but also including 7 members of the LAW (Loyal Arthurian Warband.

As you might expect from an academic, the volume is well annotated, and filled with citations. It is also highly readable, as academic writing goes. The areas of inquiry for this study were limited to the general topics of Druidic perspectives on the meaning of life, Druidic interpretations of death, well-being, and misfortune, and Druidic approaches to seeking guidance, and relating to the unknown. He also includes chapters on the relationship between (some) contemporary Druids and Stonehenge, and the pathways to conversion from other religious paths to Druidry.

The weakness of the study primarily stems from self-selection and sampling biases. Cooper admits that his access to sources was limited. He was able to survey and interview a few senior Druids in each of the three aforementioned organizations, who were willing to speak to an outsider. A few of those sources invited him to observe their public rituals, after which Cooper spoke with a few more participants, whom he met at those rituals. Given the diversity of Druidic beliefs and practices represented by the various Druid groups, groves, and teaching organizations scattered about the globe, and given the differences in perspective between those Druids who feel comfortable being open about their beliefs and practices and those who must remain private about their beliefs in order to avoid discriminatory retaliation, or worse, and given the exclusion from the study of solitary Druids, and Druids of other Druidry group affiliations, the results of this study are of limited value as a general study of Contemporary Druidry.

It is worth a glance, as part of a broad literature survey on Druidry, but it is not a comprehensive, stand-alone reference.

Braiding Sweetgrass

Braiding Sweetgrass: Indigenous Wisdom, Scientific Knowledge, and the Teachings of Plants,” by Robin Wall Kimmerer, is an inspiring book of essays exploring various ways of understanding and interacting with the natural world around us. In its pages, I learned an enormous amount about the flora, fauna, microorganisms, and ecology of the the North Eastern/Mid-Atlantic/Great Lake regions of the United States, based purely on the modern, scientific perspective of the field of botany. But Kimmerer also shared some of the myths and traditions of the indigenous peoples of that land, which offer another, and perhaps a wiser, approach to interacting with nature than does the scientific method, alone – an approach grounded in the dual themes of gratitude and reciprocity.

The book begins with the creation myth of the indigenous peoples of the Great Lakes region of the United States: Skywoman Falling. In that story, Skywoman falls from Skyworld to Earth (a water world), bearing a bundle of seeds from the Tree of Life. The animals already present on Earth risk their lives to save her from drowning, and pile some mud on Turtle’s back, to give her a safe place to rest and recover. In an act of gratitude, and reciprocity for their kindness, Skywoman dances to extend the reach of the new land, and scatters the seeds of all the plants of the world, introducing all the plant teachers, food plants, and medicine plants of the world. And her gifts to the world continue to care for us, even to this day. With this simple tale, Kimmerer launches her argument that nature works as a gift economy, which can only survive so long as all participants harvest wisely, nurture the givers, and reciprocate rather than greedily grabbing for all they can get away with in the present moment.

An interesting point she raises is that this focus on gratitude and reciprocity becomes easier when the language people use to refer to it speaks of the world in terms of living beings, rather than as a conglomeration of soul-less “its” to be used or ignored, as a mere, inanimate resource. This also makes it easier to remember the difference between times when profiting from the fruits of your own labor is appropriate, and times when your receipt of an unbidden blessing or bounty, freely given you by Nature, is meant to be freely shared with your neighbors.

The essays she uses to illustrate and support these thematic points are all so rich in fascinating detail, that the book bears many repeated readings, and each time I pick it up, I learn or relearn something wonderful. My words can not possibly do it justice. I highly recommend that you read this book – or better yet, buy three copies, and give two away. I know I will!

 

A Sand County Almanac

A Sand County Almanac, by Aldo Leopold, is a moving book of essays about Leopold’s experiences with the natural world, on his family’s weekend getaways to their “sand farm” in Wisconsin (as well as elsewhere in the United States of America). The essays both celebrate the wonders of nature, and provide a philosophical analysis of modern man’s relationship with nature – or lack thereof.

Leopold offers several critical insights on the problem of mankind’s misguided relationship with the natural world, beautifully illustrating the reality that our modern lives often make it impossible for people to even see, let alone interpret the world beyond their noses. He does this repeatedly throughout the book, in lyrical passages such as these:

“There are two spiritual dangers of not owning a farm. One is the danger of supposing that breakfast comes from the grocery, and the other that heat comes from the furnace.” (p. 6)

“…To steal a hunt, either go far into the wilderness where no one has been, or else find some undiscovered place under everybody’s nose. Few hunters know that grouse exist in Adams County for when they drive through it, they see only a waste of jack-pines and scrub oaks. This is because the highway intersects a series of west-running creeks, each of which heads in a swamp, but drops to the river through dry sand-barrens. Naturally, the highway intersects these swampless barrens, but just above the highway, and behind the screen of dry scrub, every creeklet expands into a broad ribbon of swamp, a sure haven for grouse.” (p. 55-56)

Then, throughout his writing, Aldo Leopold tacitly encourages us to look, to reflect, and to really see the wild world, and to learn from our personal observations the true nature of life, in its many forms, and to do so from the perspective of the wild, itself.

He offers up the essay, “Good Oak,” suggesting a new perspective on history, from the point-of-view of an oak tree that has lived through many ages. It encouraged me to try to take the long view on events, and not become distressed and distracted by things that will simply pass with time. In addition, considering the life of that good oak as an actor, rather than as an object, enabled me to see it anew, as a harvester of sunlight, which the tree sequesters as wood for later use. How many other quiet, motionless actors are at work, giving masterful performances in their God-given roles? The question, alone, demands attention, reflection, and reverence for things so often overlooked.

In “A Mighty Fortress” (pg. 73-77), Leopold offers an new perspective on trees and tree diseases. When considering only the life and health of an individual tree, I often have strong opinions regarding what should be done to help that one tree thrive. When considering the ecosystem that offers context to the life of that tree, however, my opinions change. The cycles of Nature require the decline of some organisms, in order to support the health of others. This is a truth that I have long understood, intellectually, as a student of ecology. However, Leopold’s encouragement to think like a raccoon, or grouse, or wild bee, left me with a deep spiritual knowing of the importance of disease and decay in a forest.

A similar perspective shift was suggested in “Thinking Like a Mountain” (pg. 129-133), in which Leopold considered the perspective of a mountain on the relative value of deer and wolves. His observation of the role-relationships between humans, the wolf, the deer, and the flora of a mountainside forces one to consider that a single thriving species may endanger the well-being of an overall ecosystem. Trades and balances are always in play, many of them deeply and darkly occult — until it is far too late. The flora of a mountain are laid to waste by an overabundance of deer. Recovery may come only after decades, or never. And all for the want of a hungry wolf.

For a purely academic exercise in perspective shifting, I also very much enjoyed “Odyssey” (pg. 104-108), which followed the travels of an endlessly recycled atom, in nature, in the wild, and then in man-damaged land.

This practice of carefully observing, and constantly changing perspective in this manner, has much to teach us about ourselves and our biases, as well as teaching us about the other manifestations of the Great Miracle of Life, and its needs, preferences, hopes, and fears.  Furthermore, Leopold speaks of even greater gifts of wisdom to be gleaned by watching for signs of the numenous aspects of nature, of which he says:

“…the significance of which is inexpressible in terms of contermporary science.  A philosopher has called this imponderable essence the numenon of material things.  It stands in contradistinction to phenomenon, which is ponderable and predictable, even to the tossings and turnings of the remotest star.”  (p. 138)

It is this focus on seeking out and attempting to connect with the “numenon of material things” that ties ecological study (for a deep intellectual understanding of the worlds at our fingertips), to reverent observation and perspective shifting (for an empathic understanding of the world that we study), and finally, to the act of forging a spiritual connection with the living essence of the world itself.  The reward for this effort is described beautifully in this passage of A Sand County Almanac:

This song of the waters is audible to every ear, but there is other music in these hills, by no means audible to all.  To hear even a few notes of it, you must first live here for a long time, and you must know the speech of hills and rivers. Then on a still night, when the campfire is low and the Pleiades have climbed over rimrocks, sit quietly and listen for a wolf to howl, and think hard of everything you have seen and tried to understand. Then you may hear it — a vast pulsing harmony — its score inscribed on a thousand hills, its notes the lives and deaths of plants and animals, its rhythms spanning the seconds and the centuries.”  (p. 149)

I highly recommend this book to anyone wishing to connect more deeply with nature, or wanting to learn how to listen for that magical music of the hills.

Nature’s Temples

“Nature’s Temples: The Complex World of Old-Growth Forests,” by Joan Maloof (with illustrations by Andrew Joslin), is a profoundly inspirational work of science writing that describes the structure and ecology of old-growth forests.

The book begins with an awe-inspiring overview of the history of forests on Earth, the earliest known from fossil-records dating from 383 million years ago! Maloof discusses the role of forests in removing carbon from the atmosphere, and the surprising discovery that the largest, oldest trees are far more effective at this task than a multitude of younger, smaller, fast-growing trees. She presents a convincing case for the preservation of old-growth forests, on the grounds that they are essential for the survival and well-being of all other life on Earth.

Maloof then goes on to make the reader fall in love with all the living beings found in old-growth forests, one short chapter at a time. She introduces us, first, to the trees themselves, then one at a time to the birds, amphibians, snails, insects, herb plants, mosses, fungi, lichens, worms and mammals that are resident in old-growth forests. And it is truly a book of wonders.

One of the things I had always wondered was how deer and elk could find sufficient food in an old-growth redwood forest, in which the browsable branch tips are hundreds of feet high. The answer: Although the herbaceous understory might be shaded out, a rain of lichen from the lofty canopy provides ample nitrogen-rich food for them. But what is a lichen? It is a magical symbiotic alliance between photosynthesizing algae and mineral-harvesting fungi! Mushroom salad. And I had no idea how amazingly diverse was the world population of lichens, especially within the remaining old-growth forests.

The most surprising thing I learned from this book was that the (mostly non-native) worms found in North American forests north of the ice-age moraines – areas that had once been covered in glacial ice – are in fact doing more harm than good to the forests in which they are found. In order to develop the rich biodiversity that enables a forest to thrive into grand old age, a thick layer of forest-floor duff must be allowed to accumulate. The moist, decaying duff at the surface of the forest floor supports diverse fungi, which in turn support diverse plant life, and allow for the germination of tree seeds, which might otherwise lie dormant. If too many worms begin churning under the duff, too quickly, that mechanism for growing diversity in the forest is disrupted, impeding the growth and healthy development of the forest! And I had always assumed that worms were good for the trees!

Live and learn.

In fact, there are so many new things to learn, in the pages of “Nature’s Temples,” that the book bears repeated readings. It is a definite must-have volume for the shelves of a Druid library.